Skip to Main content
Juicy Lucy BBQ

Juicy Lucy BBQ

We are not accepting online orders right now.
Starters
Handhelds
Burgers
Entrees
Sides
Kids
Desserts
Soft Drinks
Family Orders

Popular Items

  • Mozzarella Sticks
    Mozzarella Sticks
    $11.00

    Delicious battered sticks fried to perfection.

  • Quarter Pound Smash
    Quarter Pound Smash
    $9.00

    4 oz of fresh ground brisket topped with American cheese and served with lettuce and tomato and served with a side of fries.

Starters

Appetizers

Get started with an appetizer!
  • Chicken Fingers (Appetizer)
    Chicken Fingers (Appetizer)
    $9.00Out of stock

    Four (4) fresh chicken strips, battered and fried.

  • Mozzarella Sticks
    Mozzarella Sticks
    $11.00

    Delicious battered sticks fried to perfection.

  • Fried Pickles
    Fried Pickles
    $11.00

    Battered pickles fried to perfection.

  • Donna Summer Fries
    Donna Summer Fries
    $10.00

    Our own take on the classic disco fries!! Our fresh cut fries smothered in brown gravy and topped with your choice of American or Mozzarella cheese.

  • Fried Cheese Curds
    Fried Cheese Curds
    $14.00

    Delicious cheese curds fried to perfection.

  • Brisket Poutine
    Brisket Poutine
    $19.00Out of stock

    Fries covered with chopped brisket, fried cheese curds, and our rendered brisket gravy!

Wings

Fried chicken wings served naked or breaded with your choice of sauce.
  • 6 Wingy Thingys
    6 Wingy Thingys
    $7.50Out of stock

    Six (6) wingy thingys (our pet name for chicken wings), naked or breaded, with your choice of sauce.

  • 12 Wingy Thingys
    12 Wingy Thingys
    $15.00Out of stock

    A dozen wings with your choice of sauce.

  • 24 Wingy Thingys
    24 Wingy Thingys
    $30.00Out of stock

    Two dozen wings with the sauce of your choice, buffalo or barbecue.

  • 50 Wingy Thingys
    50 Wingy Thingys
    $62.50Out of stock

    Fifty (50) total wings with the sauce of your choice: buffalo or barbecue.

  • 100 Wingy Thingys
    100 Wingy Thingys
    $125.00Out of stock

Salads

Try one of our signature salads!
  • Caesar Alla Lucy
    Caesar Alla Lucy
    $8.00

    Our twist on the classic! Romaine topped with our homemade roasted garlic Caesar dressing, shaved Parmesan and croutons.

  • Juicy Lucy Wedge
    Juicy Lucy Wedge
    $9.00

    Iceberg wedges drenched with our homemade blue cheese dressing and topped with our in-house smoked bacon crumbles.


Handhelds

Sandwiches

All our sandwiches are served with fries.
  • Chicken Sandwich (Fried Lucy)
    Chicken Sandwich (Fried Lucy)
    $12.00

    Fried whole boneless chicken thigh served on a brioche bun with fries and mayo and coleslaw on the side.

  • Chipotle Pulled Pork Sandwich
    Chipotle Pulled Pork Sandwich
    $12.00

    Shredded spare rib and pulled pork mixed together and covered with our proprietary Chipotle mix - this one packs a little bit of a punch! Served on a brioche bun with a side of fries.

  • Grilled Chicken Sandwich
    Grilled Chicken Sandwich
    $13.00

    Grilled chicken breast served on a brioche bun with lettuce and tomato.

  • Pulled Pork Sandwich (Porky's Revenge)
    Pulled Pork Sandwich (Porky's Revenge)
    $14.00Out of stock

    Pulled pork smothered in our proprietary bbq sauce and served on a brioche bun with fries.

  • Turkey Club
    Turkey Club
    $17.00Out of stock

    Smoked turkey, bacon, lettuce, and tomato on toasted bread served with a side of fries.

  • Spicy Chicken Sandwich (Spicy Lucy)
    Spicy Chicken Sandwich (Spicy Lucy)
    $14.00

    Fried whole boneless chicken thigh served on a brioche bun with fries and topped with pepperjack cheese, spicy mayo, and jalapeno peppers to give it a spicy kick.

  • Austin Cheesesteak
    Austin Cheesesteak
    $18.00Out of stock

    Our version of the Philly classic! Moist brisket piled high with melted cheese, peppers, and grilled onions and served on a toasted hero. Served with a side of fries.

  • Pastrami  Club Sandwich
    Pastrami Club Sandwich
    $19.00Out of stock

    Sliced smoked pastrami brisket sandwich served with a side of fries.

  • Chopped Brisket Sandwich
    Chopped Brisket Sandwich
    $19.00Out of stock

    Our award-winning brisket chopped and served with BBQ sauce and served on freshly baked brioche bun with a side of fries.

  • Chicken Cheesesteak
    Chicken Cheesesteak
    $16.00

    Chopped grilled chicken piled high with melted cheese, peppers, and grilled onions and served on a toasted hero. Served with a side of fries.

Sliders

Mini versions of some of our most popular sandwiches. Three (3) sliders served with fries.
  • Cheeseburger Sliders
    Cheeseburger Sliders
    $13.00

    Three (3) mini-burgers drenched with cheese and served with a side of fries.

  • Pulled Pork Sliders
    Pulled Pork Sliders
    $13.00Out of stock

    Three (3) mini-sandwiches loaded with pulled pork, drenched with barbecue sauce and served with a side of fries and coleslaw.

  • Brisket Sliders
    Brisket Sliders
    $18.00Out of stock

    Three (3) mini-sandwiches loaded with chopped brisket and barbecue sauce and served with a side of fries.


Burgers

Lucy's Smash Burgers

Smash burger - not a hamburger - a ball of ground brisket "smashed" onto the grill to char the edges and lock in the juices for a delicious treat. The result is glorious... Smash burgers are served with fries.
  • Quarter Pound Smash
    Quarter Pound Smash
    $9.00

    4 oz of fresh ground brisket topped with American cheese and served with lettuce and tomato and served with a side of fries.

  • Half Pound Smash
    Half Pound Smash
    $14.00

    8 oz of fresh ground brisket topped with American cheese and served with lettuce and tomato and served with a side of fries.

  • Bacon Cheeseburger Smash
    Bacon Cheeseburger Smash
    $17.00

    8 oz half pound smash burger topped with bacon, American cheese and caramelized onions, and served with lettuce and tomato and served with a side of fries.

  • One Pound Smash
    One Pound Smash
    $20.00

    Two 8 oz half pound smash burgers topped with American cheese and served with lettuce and tomato and served with a side of fries.

Signature Smash Burgers

Our customized smash burgers - found only at Juicy Lucy BBQ! Served with a side of fries.
  • Angry Texan
    Angry Texan
    $17.00

    A Half Pound Smash topped with Pepperjack, chipotle ketchup, fried jalapeños, lettuce, and tomato and served with fries.

  • Juicy Lucy Burger
    Juicy Lucy Burger
    $18.00

    Ground brisket and short rib, stuffed with American cheese, lettuce, and tomato and served with fries.

  • Beyond Burger w/Numu Mozzarella
    Beyond Burger w/Numu Mozzarella
    $14.00

    Beyond Burger made from plant-based meat served with shredded Numu Mozzarella cheese, lettuce, tomato, and a side of fries.


Entrees

From the Smokehouse

Entrees from our commercial smokehouse - all our smoked meats are slow-cooked for hours. Served with fries.
  • Pulled Pork
    Pulled Pork
    $14.00Out of stock

    Pulled pork smothered in bbq sauce and served with a side of fries.

  • Smoked Turkey
    Smoked Turkey
    $15.00Out of stock

    Delicious sliced smoked turkey, served with a side of fries

  • Lucy's Spare Ribs
    Lucy's Spare Ribs
    $18.00Out of stock

    1/3 of a rack of our award-winning pork ribs and served with a side of fries.

  • Smoked Pastrami Brisket
    Smoked Pastrami Brisket
    $19.00Out of stock

    Our smoked pastrami brisket, served with a side of fries

  • Smoked Brisket
    Smoked Brisket
    $19.00Out of stock

    Our award-winning smoked brisket, served with a side of fries.

From the Kitchen

Delicous items made fresh right in our kitchen. Served with fries (except the Mac Attack).
  • Smoked Kielbasa Sausage
    Smoked Kielbasa Sausage
    $10.00

    Smoked pork kielbasa served with pickles, onion, and a side of fries.

  • Fried Chicken Thighs
    Fried Chicken Thighs
    $11.00

    Delicious fried chicken thigh served on a bed of lettuce with a slice of tomato and a side of fries.

  • Chicken Fingers Entree
    Chicken Fingers Entree
    $11.00Out of stock

    Six (6) fresh chicken strips, battered and fried, and served with a side of fries.

  • Barbecued Chicken
    Barbecued Chicken
    $14.00Out of stock

    A half-chicken barbecued to perfection and served with a side of fries.

  • Grilled Chicken Entree
    Grilled Chicken Entree
    $13.00

    Two (2) grilled chicken breast served with lettuce, tomato, and a side of fries.

  • The Mac Attack
    The Mac Attack
    $20.00Out of stock

    A large bowl of mac and cheese loaded with sliced brisket, pulled pork, and ribs. No side.

  • Chicken Parm Hero
    Chicken Parm Hero
    $18.00Out of stock

    Chicken cutlets on a hero roll - drenched with homemade marinara sauce and fresh cheese, and served with fries.


Sides

Comfort Food

Homemade side dishes made fresh in our kitchen!
  • Hand Cut Fries
    Hand Cut Fries
    $5.00
  • Homemade Mac & Cheese
    Homemade Mac & Cheese
    $7.00Out of stock

    Our homemade blend of cavatappi pasta drenched in four (4) different cheeses and made fresh from scratch.

  • Homemade Cornbread
    Homemade Cornbread
    $7.00
  • Fresh Coleslaw
    Fresh Coleslaw
    $7.00
  • Fresh Onion Rings
    Fresh Onion Rings
    $7.00

    Fresh onions breaded and fried to perfection, and served with a spicy sweet mayo on the side.

  • Sweet Potato Casserole
    Sweet Potato Casserole
    $7.00
  • Baked Beans (No Brisket)
    Baked Beans (No Brisket)
    $7.00

    Baked beans made from scratch.

  • Brisket Baked Beans
    Brisket Baked Beans
    $8.00Out of stock

    Baked beans made from scratch and topped with chopped brisket.

Vegetables

Fresh vegetables fried, grilled or steamed right in our kitchen!
  • Corn on the Cob
    Corn on the Cob
    $7.00Out of stock

    Three pieces of fresh corn on the cob lightly buttered and salted, and sprinkled with parsley.

  • Brussels Sprouts
    Brussels Sprouts
    $8.00Out of stock

    Flash-fried Brussels sprout tossed in garlic salt and served with a side of ranch.

  • Sauteed Broccoli
    Sauteed Broccoli
    $7.00Out of stock

    Fresh broccoli sauteed in garlic.


Kids

Lil' Lucys

For the little ones! Served with a side of fries and a 12 oz iced tea.
  • Lil' Grilled Cheese
    Lil' Grilled Cheese
    $10.00

    The American classic! Comes with fries and 12oz iced tea.

  • Lil' Mac and Cheese
    Lil' Mac and Cheese
    $10.00Out of stock

    Kids order of mac and cheese with fries and a 12oz iced tea.

  • Lil' Chicken Fingers
    Lil' Chicken Fingers
    $10.00Out of stock

    Four (4) fresh chicken strips battered and fried, and served with fries and a 12 oz iced tea.

  • Lil' Cheeseburger
    Lil' Cheeseburger
    $10.00

    Every kid loves a cheeseburger! Comes with fries and 12oz iced tea.


Desserts

Sweets For the Sweet

  • Churros
    $7.00

    Three churros!


Soft Drinks

Water

  • 16.9 Oz Poland Spring
    16.9 Oz Poland Spring
    $2.00

    Image is an example, brand may vary.

  • S. Pellegrino Sparkling (16.9 oz)
    S. Pellegrino Sparkling (16.9 oz)
    $2.50

12oz Cans

  • Coke
    Coke
    $2.00Out of stock
  • Diet Coke
    Diet Coke
    $2.00Out of stock
  • Pepsi
    Pepsi
    $2.00Out of stock
  • Diet Pepsi
    Diet Pepsi
    $2.00Out of stock
  • Sprite
    Sprite
    $2.00Out of stock
  • Brisk Iced Tea
    Brisk Iced Tea
    $2.00
  • Mountain Dew
    Mountain Dew
    $2.00Out of stock
  • Ginger Ale
    Ginger Ale
    $2.00Out of stock
  • Ruby Red Grapefruit Seltzer
    Ruby Red Grapefruit Seltzer
    $2.00Out of stock

20 Oz Bottles

  • Coke 20 oz
    Coke 20 oz
    $3.00
  • Diet Coke 20 oz
    Diet Coke 20 oz
    $3.00
  • Pepsi 20 oz
    Pepsi 20 oz
    $3.00
  • Diet Pepsi 20 oz
    Diet Pepsi 20 oz
    $3.00
  • Sprite 20 oz
    Sprite 20 oz
    $3.00
  • Root Beer 20 oz
    Root Beer 20 oz
    $3.00Out of stock
  • Dr. Pepper 20 oz
    Dr. Pepper 20 oz
    $3.00Out of stock
  • Mountain Dew 20 oz
    Mountain Dew 20 oz
    $3.00
  • Ginger Ale 20 oz
    Ginger Ale 20 oz
    $3.00Out of stock
  • Seltzer 20 oz
    Seltzer 20 oz
    $3.00

Prime Energy Drink

  • Prime Red
    Prime Red
    $3.50Out of stock
  • Prime Blue
    Prime Blue
    $3.50
  • Prime Green
    Prime Green
    $3.50

Snapple

  • Snapple Peach Tea (16 oz)
    Snapple Peach Tea (16 oz)
    $2.50Out of stock
  • Snapple Zero-Sugar Peach Tea (16 oz)
    Snapple Zero-Sugar Peach Tea (16 oz)
    $3.00Out of stock
  • Snapple Peach Tea (20 oz)
    Snapple Peach Tea (20 oz)
    $3.00
  • Snapple Lemon Tea (20 oz)
    Snapple Lemon Tea (20 oz)
    $3.00
  • Snapple Raspberry Tea (20 oz)
    Snapple Raspberry Tea (20 oz)
    $3.00Out of stock
  • Snapple Mango Madness
    Snapple Mango Madness
    $3.00Out of stock
  • Snapple Apple
    Snapple Apple
    $3.00Out of stock
  • Snapple Kiwi Strawberry
    Snapple Kiwi Strawberry
    $3.00

Gatorade

  • Gatorade Red (20 oz)
    Gatorade Red (20 oz)
    $2.50Out of stock
  • Gatorade Orange (20 oz)
    Gatorade Orange (20 oz)
    $2.50Out of stock
  • Gatorade Yellow (20 oz)
    Gatorade Yellow (20 oz)
    $2.50Out of stock

2-Liter Bottles

  • Coke (2 ltr)
    Coke (2 ltr)
    $4.50Out of stock
  • Diet Coke (2 ltr)
    Diet Coke (2 ltr)
    $4.50
  • Sprite (2 ltr)
    Sprite (2 ltr)
    $4.50Out of stock
  • Pepsi (2 ltr)
    Pepsi (2 ltr)
    $4.50Out of stock
  • Diet Pepsi (2 ltr)
    Diet Pepsi (2 ltr)
    $4.50Out of stock

Family Orders

Family Cookouts

When you need a family-sized order, we're here for you! Choose one of our suggested or build your own!
  • Build-Your-Own Cookout
    Build-Your-Own Cookout
    $59.00Out of stock

    Your cookout, your way! You choose which meats to include. Choose five (5) meats in any combination - including multiple selections of the same meat - then select your sides.

  • Cookout For Two
    Cookout For Two
    $39.00Out of stock

    Smoked brisket, pulled pork, smoked kielbasa, grilled chicken cutlet, and ribs along with two sides. The perfect meal for two!

  • Family Cookout
    Family Cookout
    $99.00Out of stock

    One pound each of smoked brisket, pulled pork, smoked kielbasa, grilled chicken cutlet, and half a rack of ribs along with your choice of 4 sides.

  • Extended Family Cookout
    Extended Family Cookout
    $189.00Out of stock

    Two pounds each of smoked brisket, pulled pork, smoked kielbasa, grilled chicken cutlet, and a rack of ribs along with your choice of 8 sides.

Party Trays - From the Smokehouse

  • Rack of Lucy's Spare Ribs
    Rack of Lucy's Spare Ribs
    $45.00Out of stock

    A full rack of ribs (12 pieces).

  • Pulled Pork - Half Tray
    Pulled Pork - Half Tray
    $50.00Out of stock

    Choose the size for your party!

  • Smoked Turkey - Half Tray
    Smoked Turkey - Half Tray
    $70.00Out of stock

    Choose the size for your party!

  • Smoked Pastrami Brisket - Half Tray
    Smoked Pastrami Brisket - Half Tray
    $120.00Out of stock

    Choose the size for your party!

  • Smoked Brisket - Half Tray
    Smoked Brisket - Half Tray
    $120.00Out of stock

    Choose the size for your party!

Party Trays - From the Kitchen

  • Chicken Fingers - Half Tray
    Chicken Fingers - Half Tray
    $50.00

    Fresh grilled chicken strips, battered and fried.

  • Fried Chicken Thighs - Half Tray
    $50.00

    Choose the size for your party!

  • Barbecue Chicken - Half Tray
    Barbecue Chicken - Half Tray
    $60.00Out of stock

    Choose the size for your party!

  • Smoked Kielbasa - Half Tray
    $50.00Out of stock
  • Cheeseburger Sliders - Half Tray
    $75.00

    18 cheeseburger sliders.

Party Trays - Sides and Salads

  • Hand Cut Fries - Half Tray
    Hand Cut Fries - Half Tray
    $20.00

    A half tray of cripsy french fries.

  • Sauteed Broccoli - Half Tray
    Sauteed Broccoli - Half Tray
    $25.00Out of stock

    A half tray of fresh broccoli sauteed in garlic.

  • Corn on the Cob - Half Tray
    Corn on the Cob - Half Tray
    $30.00Out of stock

    A half tray (24 pieces) of delicious corn on the cob.

  • Brussels Sprouts - Half Tray
    Brussels Sprouts - Half Tray
    $30.00Out of stock

    A half tray of flash-fried Brussels sprouts.

  • Cornbread - Half Tray
    Cornbread - Half Tray
    $30.00

    A half tray of homemade cornbread.

  • Mac and Cheese - Half Tray
    Mac and Cheese - Half Tray
    $40.00

    A half tray of everyone's favorite: mac and cheese!

  • Coleslaw - Half Tray

    A half tray of coleslaw.

  • Coleslaw - Half Tray
    Coleslaw - Half Tray
    $40.00Out of stock

    A half tray of coleslaw.

  • Sweet Potato Casserole - Half Tray
    Sweet Potato Casserole - Half Tray
    $30.00

    A half tray of delicious sweet potato casserole.

  • Brisket Baked Beans - Half Tray
    Brisket Baked Beans - Half Tray
    $45.00Out of stock

    Baked beans topped with chopped brisket.

  • Onion Rings - Half Tray
    $25.00

    A half tray of cripsy french fries.

Party Trays - Appetizers

  • Mozzarella Sticks - Half Tray
    Mozzarella Sticks - Half Tray
    $50.00

    A half tray of fried mozzarella sticks.

  • Fried Pickles - Half Tray
    Fried Pickles - Half Tray
    $50.00
  • Fried Cheese Curds - Half Tray
    Fried Cheese Curds - Half Tray
    $70.00

    A half tray of fried cheese curds.

  • Brisket Poutine - Half Tray
    $80.00Out of stock

Juicy Lucy BBQ Location and Ordering Hours

(718) 317-7427
20 Jefferson Blvd, Staten Island, NY 10312
Open now • Closes at 9:45PM
Order online
This site is powered byToast logo
Terms of Service | Privacy Statement